The 7 largest car insurance companies: Which is cheapest? Geico : $1,198. State Farm : $1,511. Progressive : $1,766. Liberty Mutual : $1,778. Allstate : $1,834. Farmers : $1,865. Here are some awesome perks you get with your cheap car insurance policy from GEICO: Fast and fair claim and policy service. Outstanding 24/7 customer service has your back—and you can talk to a real person. If you're not paying in full, low down payments and convenient payment plans make things How to compare car insurance quotes. 1. Gather your information. To quickly and easily compare car insurance quotes, have the following on hand: 2. Choose the right liability car insurance coverage levels. 3. Decide if you need full coverage car insurance. 4. Collect and compare car insurance